When it comes to industrial water filtration, selecting the right underdrain system is crucial for the long-term performance, maintenance, and efficiency of your filtration tank. The two most common types of underdrains—welded underdrains and removable underdrains—each offer distinct advantages depending on your filtration needs.
At Everfilt®, we specialize in manufacturing high-quality underdrains, with our standard wedge wire underdrain options constructed from 304SS or 316SS stainless steel. Let's explore the key differences between welded and removable underdrains, and explain why stainless steel underdrains are superior to traditional PVC plastic options.
Welded Underdrain
The welded underdrain is the industry standard, offering reliability and durability. At Everfilt®, our welded underdrain design features a main hub with laterals extending outward from it. All the components are welded together, creating a fixed structure that forms the base of the underdrain.
Key Features:
Constructed from 304SS or optional 316SS for enhanced corrosion resistance.
The laterals are securely welded to the main hub for robust, long-lasting performance.
This design offers simplicity, reducing the number of individual components.
Advantages:
Cost-effective: Since the entire system is welded together, there are fewer individual components, making the welded underdrain a more cost-effective solution upfront.
Durability: The welded construction ensures a high level of durability, particularly when using 304SS or 316SS materials, which are known for their resistance to corrosion and wear.
Low Maintenance: A welded underdrain is designed to last for many years without requiring significant maintenance.
Drawbacks:
Limited Repairability: If any part of the underdrain becomes damaged, the entire assembly may need to be replaced, which can be costly and time-consuming.
Tank Access: Because the system is welded in place, any repair work might require tank modifications or cutting, especially if damage occurs after installation.
Removable Underdrain
The removable underdrain offers a more flexible solution for filtration systems that may need future adjustments or repairs. While the removable design is also constructed from high-quality 304SS or 316SS wedge wire, it features a threaded assembly.
Key Features:
Threaded Design: The center hub and each lateral are threaded, allowing for individual parts to be easily removed or replaced.
Rebuildable: Individual components like the laterals or hub can be purchased separately and replaced without damaging the tank.
Advantages:
Repairability: The most significant advantage of a removable underdrain is its rebuildable nature. If one part of the system is damaged or broken, it can be removed and replaced without having to replace the entire system.
Ease of Maintenance: All parts can be removed from the tank via the side-access manway, making maintenance much easier and less invasive.
Long-term Cost Efficiency: While the initial cost is higher due to the labor-intensive installation and the number of components, the ability to replace parts individually can save money over time, particularly for facilities that anticipate future wear and tear.
Drawbacks:
Higher Initial Cost: Because of the additional components and more complex assembly, the initial cost of a removable underdrain system is higher than that of a welded underdrain.
More Complex Installation: The installation process requires more labor and precision due to the threaded connections.
Why Stainless Steel Underdrains Are Superior to PVC Plastic Underdrains
While both welded and removable underdrains are available in 304SS or 316SS stainless steel, some filtration systems still use PVC plastic underdrains. However, stainless steel options offer significant advantages over PVC underdrains.
1. Durability & Strength Stainless steel underdrains are far more durable and resistant to damage compared to PVC. 304SS and 316SS stainless steel are both resistant to corrosion, high temperatures, and wear, making them ideal for use in harsh industrial environments. In contrast, PVC plastic can become brittle over time, especially when exposed to UV light or extreme temperatures, leading to cracking and failure.
2. Better Flow Rates Stainless steel wedge wire underdrains provide better flow distribution and filtration efficiency compared to plastic underdrains. The precision of the wedge wire design ensures uniform flow and prevents clogging, resulting in better performance over time.
3. Longer Lifespan Stainless steel underdrains can last for decades without the need for significant repairs or replacements. PVC underdrains, on the other hand, degrade much faster and often require more frequent maintenance, repairs, or full replacements.
4. Environmental Impact Using stainless steel underdrains, particularly with 304SS or 316SS, has a lower long-term environmental impact. Stainless steel is fully recyclable and doesn't release harmful chemicals into the environment, unlike PVC, which can release toxins when it breaks down or is disposed of.
Whether you choose a welded underdrain for its cost-effectiveness and simplicity, or a removable underdrain for its flexibility and ease of repair, both options from Everfilt® offer superior performance compared to PVC plastic underdrains. With the durability, corrosion resistance, and environmental benefits of 304SS and 316SS stainless steel, you'll ensure your filtration system operates at peak efficiency for years to come.
If you’re looking to make the best choice for your facility, Everfilt® has you covered with high-quality, customizable underdrain solutions that meet your specific filtration needs.
Comments